Saturday, October 2, 2010

Who should win the NL MVP Award?

There's a very good chance that Albert Pujols will not win the NL MVP Award for the for time since 2007.  It's probably going to be Joey Votto, and it will be well-deserved. 

Jayson Stark picked Votto in his recent year-end awards article, and after going through all of his excellent stats, put that one of the key reasons is that Votto has carried the Reds to the playoffs.  The Reds, as in the franchise that hasn't made the playoffs since 1995 and shocked the baseball world by winning the NL Central this year.

Despite a relatively low batting average (for him), Albert Pujols leads the NL in R, RBI and HR, and he would be the first NL player to do that since Mike Schmidt in 1981.

Carlos Gonzalez (Rockies) has amazing numbers too, but in a year when it's this close, it's probably going to someone on a playoff team.  That's not entirely fair (a team could falter down the stretch because of pitching while the MVP candidate is scorching), but it's a factor. 

               Votto    Pujols    Gonzalez
BA        #2 (NL)    6              1
OPS          1          2              3
OBP          1          2              14
SLG          1          1              1
HR            3          1              4
RBI           3          1              2
R               4          1              2
H               6          5             1
BB            3           2             79
RC            2           1             3 
TB             3          2              1
SB             26        29           11
RISP         2           4             3
BA: RO     1          14            6     

It could go to any one of these three players and be deserved, but it's probably going to be Votto.  He'll be seen as the key player in resurrecting one of baseball's great franchises, and he's the only one of the three that will be heading to the playoffs. 

Should he win? All three of them have the numbers, but Votto was also in the right place at the right time and took advantage.  It'll be tough for Pujols to lose if he leads the NL in R, HR and RBI, but he'll still be the favorite to win it next year.


  1. What about Strike outs, Pujols blows both of them in the water 2 to 1 in that cat. nobody ever brings that up

  2. Also was'nt in 07 when pujols was snubbed by Ryan Howard. Pujols made playoffs Ryan did not equal numbers then.

  3. Why Albert will win over Votto? Pujols has 12 more walks, 49 less strike outs, won HR and RBI titles, and it's a regular season award for the best player. The cards wouldn't have finished 10 games above .500 without Albert. They'd be hard pressed to even reach .500.

  4. When Votto puts up numbers like he did for another 2 or 3 years he then should be in the discussion of an MVP candidate. Until then, the award goes to Pujols, he was shunned by Barry Bonds in the early 2000's and now it's time for the writers to respect what an amazing career Albert has had. He will go down as probably the greatest ever!

  5. Going to be a very tight race...........Pujols by a hair.

  6. connecting device developed handbagreplica two new patented invention. The new case on smooth bezel made of tungsten steel, this extremely strong Replica watches UK high-tech composite materials exude a natural gradient shiny, polished stainless steel Replica handbags and the formation of subtle contrast. Tungsten is a tungsten powder through high temperature and pressure molded, Rolex Daytona extremely hard, hardness is almost five times that of steel, but scratch the surface so that it can also Replica Watches.


Site Meter